Talent Management Problem in China

Talent Management Injury in China Essay Sample

In this particular paper, China’s current issue with talent management –mainly due to lack of qualified university graduates for multinational companies that take part in overseas service operations, the lack of The english language skills, poor financing associated with universities, and quality-lacking curriculums– and the ways of which China can tackle with this problem by participating in talent management operations will be discussed. The answer that the paper embraces is the fact China should adapt itself to the Corporation Man model of 1950s because a talent management strategy since the current scenario in China cannot work well with the Talent upon Demand approach mainly credited to not enough talent in spite of high number of employees.

The papers will firstly define expertise management in general plus cover the historical developments in talent management, second of all give overall information about China’s talent problem with the reasons, and lastly mention the possible ways to solve the Chinese talent issue by embracing the Organization Guy model of talent administration. The main reference points is going to be Peter Cappelli’s post named “The Talent Administration Problem: Why We Need to Think Differently about Talent Management” and Diana Farrell and Andrew M. Grant’s article of “China’s Looming Talent Shortage. ” Additional sources will also be used through typically the paper. A. TALENT SUPERVISION AND HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENTS

1. Defining Talent Management

All companies or organizations require individual capital internal with their buildings. Human capital has lengthy served as one of the most significant internal functioning tool for people companies and organizations. However the production charges has been decreasing more than years due to engagement in high technology production techniques that do not require human power, individual factor will still maintain its importance in typically the future due to management’s inescapable need for human being capital to operate. Consequently, talent management is a new tool to anticipate typically the need for human money and after that to set out there a plan to satisfy this particular (Cappelli, 2008). The essential purpose of talent management is “getting the right folks with the proper skills directly into the right jobs” (Cappelli, 2008). This also signifies one of the many important internal problems of companies and organizations.

This job will be a tough one to be able to be managed; however, this is very crucial regarding success and creating competencies for your company or organization itself. In the recent many years, an increasing number of business companies have started to engage in talent management strategies. This new trend in HR reflects typically the ever increasing concerns associated with the companies on chance management, cost management and change management. Accordingly, these people see the gaps inside talent and the present potential for effective controlling and building key expertise (McCool, 2010). I believe, companies started to adapt in order to this trend simply because talent management is a good effective tool for calculating the risk that is likely to appear in the particular future, to make cost-benefit analysis to have an idea about the possibility costs of training or even hiring choices of the particular companies, and to adjust to change that occurs in the course of the years by getting able to shift your current talent resources as the way you desire whenever necessary.

Before going into the particulars of talent management developments that occurred during 1900s and 2000s, it will be important to mention the basic failures that businesses or organizations can do while engaging in talent management. Simply, we can call these failures because mismatches between supply in addition to demand and list these people as (1) having also many employees and (2) having too little talent (Cappelli, 2008). Both have their shortcomings: the first one may result in layoffs and restructurings, the second one might create talent shortages (Cappelli, 2008). Eventually, we can say that the ultimate goal of talent management can be summarized very properly in these words of Peter Cappelli: “… aim of talent management is the more general plus important task of assisting the organization achieve their overall objectives. In the business world, that aim is to make money. And making money demands that you be familiar with charges as well as the particular benefits related to your skill management choice. ” (Cappelli, 2008)

a couple of. Talent Management Practices

Talent management practices that occurred through the entire history may be analyzed by record 3 effective trends: (1) do-nothing model, (2) forecasting and succession planning design of 1950s and (3) Talent on Demand design. a. Do-nothing model:

Do-nothing model is a reactive approach that tends to make no attempt to anticipate about the possible future requirements for your business and that does not develop any plans to deal with them. In this sense, this method requires “outside hiring”: searching for your availability of talent that is essential to fulfill your company requirements in the outdoors labor market (Cappelli, 2008). It is important to be able to mention that this trend has lost its effectiveness with the proof of outside hiring as a new very costly tool regarding developing human capital. m. Bureaucratic planning model (Organization Man model):

This model, also called the Organization Man type, was the popular tendency in 1950s. Mostly, aged companies which are furthermore called “academy companies” embraced this model within their particular human capital operations. These people used very complex methods to have interaction in forecasting in addition to succession planning, which produced them the “breeding environment for talent” (Cappelli, 2008). They developed their staff internally in line along with the needs and opportunities inside the organization. On the other hand, it is extremely crucial to talk about that this model has been effective when highly predictable business was surrounding the surroundings. Nowadays, this is not really the situation that this company world faces. Everything in operation operations, from production in order to costs to sells, will be unpredictable, which does not necessarily make forecasting an successful tool for long phrase talent management strategies anymore. c. Talent on demand model:

As the failures of do-nothing and 1950s models regarding being inaccurate and pricey are actually proven, the requirement for a new perspective in talent management happened. It was obvious of which to develop employees inside or to do outside employing is quite costly, and really does not respond to the organizational needs properly. Like a response, Talent on Requirement approach started to dominate the current environment. Basically, this model: “… represents a balancing appealing –between interior development and outside hiring, in between interests of employees and those of the organization. ” (Cappelli, 2008) Futhermore crucial about this Skill on Demand model is that, not the same as the old models, it attempts to approach to the uncertainty which is present in the company environment from the different viewpoint. It seeks the methods to respond to uncertainties by adapting to these people.

Naturally, typically the method of planning staff would not use this00 type. Moreover, it accepts that will uncertainty cannot be erased by long-term plans and forecasts. Another very essential thing about Talent upon Demand method is the particular emphasis that it makes to be able to retaining talent after hiring. This is mainly because of the shortcomings of exterior hiring, and the connected problems that occurred since the business concerns: mainly, being able to attract the right employee in order to your company and in order to retain them (Cappelli, 2008). To conclude the Talent about Demand method, the phrases of Cappelli (2008) associated with this 3rd method could be beneficial: “The capability to get the right people with the right abilities into the right jobs in a cost-effective way which makes it possible for a business to adjust in addition to respond within the strategy market. ”


Even as we gave info about talent management about a general basis, we have to now learn about typically the problem in China related to talent management. Down the road, we will be capable to relate the initial plus the second parts to one another, namely, finding the finest solution of talent management for China’s growing skill shortage. China, as the particular global manufacturing leader along with low labor cost plus enormous domestic market, is now trying to increase the service-based operations, which will be one of the the majority of important indicators of economical development and growth. China’s main goals are to engage in just offshore IT and business procedure services successfully (Farrell & Grant, 2005). However, this is not very effortless for China since that experiences an important problem: expertise shortage. There are several reasons regarding that, related to advanced schooling system, domestic market plus multinational companies in the Chinese market.

The basic problems in China are as follows. Firstly, there are a high number associated with university graduates (9. 6th million in 2003) nevertheless they are not competent. They lack the functional experience as well as the skills essential for service occupations. Therefore, the top positions remain as vacancies both within domestic and multinational companies in the Chinese market. This particular problem of unqualified university graduates may be solved by simply increasing the quality of curriculums plus engaging in more efficient and fair funding among universities. This can end up being done by collaboration associated with the state with typically the private companies in buy to better reply to typically the needs of talent. Second of all, English speaking graduates are extremely few in number. Even they speak English, the particular quality is poor plus it is not enough to work efficiently in typically the multinational environment. This trouble can be overcome simply by recruiting English teachers plus training them in accordance with the university curriculums plus general profile of Chinese language students.

Additionally, there is a not enough mobility in China, which can be verified by the fact that will only one-third of Chinese university graduate students proceed to the other cities to work (Farrell & Offer, 2005). Therefore, the businesses inside China have problems together with recruiting the graduates. Fourthly, it comes with an obvious competition for talent in China, in between domestic and multinational companies. This really is mainly because regarding the vast domestic marketplace which provides good opportunities for the university teachers. Therefore , the interest associated with students in multinational firms has fallen dramatically (Schmidt, 2011). Moreover, a growing proportion of high-potential Chinese language workers see domestic employers as a better bet (Schmidt, 2011). In of which sense, multinational companies are not able to find necessary talents with regard to their organizations. Accordingly, these people are reluctant to do offshoring in China, nevertheless they somewhat prefer to go to be able to other low-wage locations such as Philippines Lastly, The far east lacks effective managers.

It has to create seventy-five, 000 leaders in 10 years to occupy typically the vacancy positions (Farrell & Grant, 2005). Yet , The far east does not have the necessary background to teach those managers. These five main problems affect the business environment –both domestic and multinational- and the policy-making realm of China. They are the main obstacles behind changing from manufacturing to service-based economy in the near future. In other phrases, these are the main obstacles right behind development. Therefore, these difficulties should be solved as quickly as possible so that will China improve its economical situation in the world, and acquire closer to being a global giant.

C. SOLUTION TO CHINA’S TALENT SHORTAGE: EMBRACING ORGANIZATION MAN MODEL After speaking about the talent shortage inside China and the main reasons for this, in this section, a possible solution to this problem will be argued. Before starting, it is very essential to realize that China needs talent management operations instantly since it exhibits both of the two problems of talent management: mismatch between supply and need, namely, having too several employees but having too little talent. Consequently , that is obvious that right now there is an urgent want for talent management inside China. However, there are numerous techniques to talent management, because discussed in the 1st section of this paper. At this point, we ought to evaluate the other conditions inside China to decide on which usually approach to use for this specific very specific case. This specific paper finds the remedy in engaging in Organization Man model of 1950s, rather than the Talent on Requirement model of 2000s, although the particular failures and shortcomings of the first one have been proven throughout the time, as well as the need to update the method to talent management has occurred.

Talent on Demand approach was this new updated edition to work more effectively and effectively. Nevertheless, typically the choice is Organization Type and there are a number of reasons for this. To begin with, it truly is obvious that Expertise on Demand method functions on the current talents and the ways to get and retain them effectively, in accordance with the particular right position and cost-savings ideas. However, the problem within China clearly reflects of which the real problem will be the lack of talent. It means that the very first step that will China should take must be creating talents, before trying to find the ways to recruit and retain them appropriately. In this sense, Organization Person model is more suitable with China’s talent supervision, since it handles teaching talents by inner operations of the companies such as employee trainings, long-term predicting and succession planning. This model tries to overcome the particular concern of obtaining shortage within internal talent simply due to the fact there was no every other way to have skills as opposed to producing them by simply the companies themselves (Cappelli, 2008). In this sense, China should:

“… build a sustainable talent development system within The far east, for China. [China should] do it proper now. ” (Thompson & Thompson, 2011) At this specific point, it is important to which training talents within the organizations because an internal process is quite time-consuming and costly. Nevertheless, it appears as the must for China within the sense that the degree of underdevelopment requires taking this step before anything else. China should position the moment and cost issue aside and increase its initiatives to training talent, since this is the first phase associated with moving to service based operations on a national basis. We see within economically developed countries, exactly where service sector has typically the highest share in GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT, that service-related posts are usually occupied by highly qualified staff with good practical abilities and university background. When China aims to obtain this end, this should become the path to end up being taken. Secondly, since Tiongkok has to train skills, the Organization Man design provides China with a much better framework of training by its succession preparing tool.

Basically, succession planning is around guessing which employee will occupy which post, many years inside advance (Cappelli, 2008). When China makes forecasts concerning the future needs for these posts, it will probably show a larger picture of the future in the sense the potentials in addition to expectations may be compared in addition to contrasted to be able to improve typically the current actions and safety measures. For example, the number of talents required could be forecasted, and long-term plans can be developed accordingly, by trying to be able to create that number associated with talents inside a given period of time of time. It may prevent China from encountering shortages of talent, from least over time. In the opinion, once again, it shows the long-term approach in the Organization Man model to talent management, which means that the final results can be attained after many yrs. Both training and sequence planning can show their own effectiveness inside the long-run since of the very character of “training” and “planning. ” Thirdly, by participating in Organization Man model, firms can decide which applicants are suitable to work regarding which experience independently, somewhat than leaving a location for the employees to determine about that (Cappelli, 2008).

This may possibly also help China with making long-term predictions concerning talent requirements. As the particular main reasons to pick Organization Man model for resolving China’s talent shortage trouble are mentioned, another suggestions for China can be to engage in Talent on Requirement approach only after totally fulfilling the requirements of Organization Man model plus enjoying the satisfying environment it can easily create. If this particular step is accomplished successfully, China will consider for preservation methods, adapting to changing environments, creating talent private pools and portfolios, structuring interior job boards within the particular business organizations, applying to be able to the techniques of outsourcing, contract-based and temporary employment, making shorter forecasts and so on, which are all of the tools of Talent about Demand approach to decrease risk and uncertainty in addition to to provide retention of talent to the companies.


Cappelli, P. (2008). Skill management for your twenty-first hundred years. Harvard Business Review, Recovered from http://hbr.org/2008/03/talent-management-for-the-twenty-first-century/ar/1

Cappelli, P. (2008). The talent management problem. Inside Talent on Demand: Handling Talent within an Age regarding Uncertainty. Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Business Press.

Farrell, D., & Offer, A. J. (2005). China’ s loomig talent lack. The McKinsey Quarterly, some, 70-79. McCool, J. Deb. (2010, March 05). Expertise management function gains impetus. Bloomberg Businessweek, Retrieved coming from http://www.businessweek.com/managing/content/mar2010/ca2010035_970348.htm Schmidt, C. (2011, March). The battle regarding china’ s talent. Harvard Business Review, Retrieved through http://hbr.org/2011/03/the-battle-for-chinas-talent/ar/1 Thompson, A. G. & Thompson, J. (2011, September 26). Building regional talent in china. HBR Blog Network, Retrieved coming from http://blogs.hbr.org/cs/2011/09/building_local_talent_in_china.html

— — — — — — — — — — — — — — –

[ 1 ]. Cappelli, P. (2008). Skill management for the twenty-first century. Harvard Business Review, Retrieved from http://hbr.org/2008/03/talent-management-for-the-twenty-first-century/ar/1 [ 2 ]. Cappelli, P. (2008). The talent management problem. In Talent on Need: Managing Talent in a good Age of Uncertainty. Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Business Press. [ 3 ]. McCool, M. D. (2010, March 05). Talent management function benefits momentum. Bloomberg Businessweek, Recovered from http://www.businessweek.com/managing/content/mar2010/ca2010035_970348.htm [ 4 ]. Cappelli, P. (2008). Typically the talent management problem. In Talent on Demand: Controlling Talent in an Age of Uncertainty. Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Business Press. [ 5 ]. Cappelli, P. (2008). Typically the talent management problem. Within Talent on Demand: Controlling Talent in an Age of Uncertainty. Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Business Press. [ 6 ]. Cappelli, P. (2008). The talent management issue. In Talent on Demand: Managing Talent in a great Age of Uncertainty. Birkenstock boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Business Push. [ 7 ]. Cappelli, L. (2008). The talent supervision problem. In Talent on Demand: Managing Talent within an Age of Uncertainty. Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Business Push. [ 8 ]. Cappelli, P. (2008). The talent management problem. In Talent about Demand: Managing Talent in an Age of Uncertainty. Birkenstock boston,

Massachusetts: Harvard Company Press. [ 9 ]. Cappelli, P. (2008). The expertise management problem. In Expertise on Demand: Managing Skill in an Regarding Uncertainty. Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Enterprise Press. [ 10 ]. Cappelli, P. (2008). The skill management problem. In Talent on Demand: Managing Skill in an Age associated with Uncertainty. Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Business Press. [ 11 ]. Cappelli, P. (2008). Typically the talent management problem. Within Talent on Demand: Managing Talent in an Age of Uncertainty. Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Business Press. [ 12 ]. Farrell, D., & Grant, A. J. (2005). China’ s loomig talent shortage. The McKinsey Quarterly, 4, 70-79. [ 13 ]. Farrell, D., & Give, A. J. (2005). China’ s loomig talent scarcity. The McKinsey Quarterly, some, 70-79. [ 14 ]. Schmidt, C. (2011, March). The particular battle for china’ s talent. Harvard Business Review, Retrieved from http://hbr.org/2011/03/the-battle-for-chinas-talent/ar/1 [ 15 ]. Schmidt, C. (2011, March). The battle with regard to china’ s talent. Harvard Business Review, Retrieved through http://hbr.org/2011/03/the-battle-for-chinas-talent/ar/1 [ 16 ]. Farrell, D., & Grant, A new. J. (2005). China’ t loomig talent shortage. The McKinsey Quarterly, 4, 70-79. [ 17 ]. Farrell, M., & Grant, A. J. (2005). China’ s loomig talent shortage. The McKinsey Quarterly, 4, 70-79. [ 18 ]. Cappelli, P. (2008). The talent management issue. In Talent on Requirement: Managing Talent within an Era of Uncertainty. Boston, Ma: Harvard Business Press. [ 19 ]. Thompson, A. P. & Thompson, J. (2011, September 26). Building nearby talent in china. HBR Blog Network, Retrieved from http://blogs.hbr.org/cs/2011/09/building_local_talent_in_china.html [ 20 ]. Cappelli, P. (2008). The expertise management problem. In Skill on Demand: Managing Skill within an Age of Doubt. Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Enterprise Press. [ 21 ]. Cappelli, P. (2008). The skill management problem. In Expertise on Demand: Managing Expertise in an Associated with Uncertainness. Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Business Press.